Client
Perth Commercial Plumbing Co (name changed)
Timeline
6 Weeks
The Challenge
Website was three years old, looked dated, and 'wasn't converting'. They thought they needed a modern, mobile-responsive rebuild.
The Real Problem
Positioning. They were trying to appeal to homeowners and commercial clients simultaneously, resulting in generic messaging that appealed to nobody.
The Result
Leads up 150%, average project value increased from $8k to $22k, and close rate improved from 25% to 40%.
What They Came to Me With
They came to me wanting a website rebuild. Their current site was three years old, looked dated, and "wasn't converting." Pretty standard story.
What they thought they needed: A modern, mobile-responsive website with better design.
What they actually needed: Well, that's what we had to figure out.
What I Found in Research
Customer Research
I interviewed eight of their recent customers. Every single one mentioned the same thing: they didn't know if this business could handle commercial projects. The website only showed residential work.
"We almost didn't call because your site just showed house bathrooms. We needed a 12-story office refit."
They were losing half their potential market because of one missing section.
Competitor Analysis
The top three competitors in Perth all positioned themselves identically: "We do it all! Residential, Commercial, Industrial, 24/7!" They were all fighting over the same generic search terms and competing purely on price quotes.
The Audit
Traffic wasn't the issue. They had 2,000 visitors a month. The issue was the exit rate on the services page: 85% of traffic dropped off immediately upon seeing the mixed bag of $200 leaky tap fixes next to $50,000 commercial fit-outs.
The Real Problem
The website wasn't the problem. Their positioning was.
They were trying to appeal to everyone - homeowners, small businesses, large commercial clients - and ending up appealing to nobody. Their messaging was generic. Their portfolio showed everything but proved nothing specific.
A website redesign without addressing the psychological positioning wouldn't have fixed a thing.
The Strategy
Here's what we decided:
- Pick a lane. They had the most experience and best margins in commercial work. That's where we focused.
- Rebuild the website with messaging that spoke directly to commercial property managers. Not homeowners. Not small businesses. One audience.
- Restructure the portfolio to show commercial projects only. Quality over quantity. Each project told the story of the problem they solved, not just pretty photos.
What We Built
Website
The rebuild took six weeks. The homepage focused entirely on commercial property managers. Copy used the exact language we heard in the customer interviews.
Portfolio section: 12 commercial projects, each with a case study format showing the problem, solution, and result. No residential work at all.
The contact form asked qualifying questions upfront so they weren't wasting time on projects they couldn't handle.
Marketing
Set up Google Ads targeting commercial property management terms. Landing pages built specifically for each service. Monthly budget tightly capped at $2k.
Systems
Implemented a basic CRM pipeline so they could actually track leads and follow up properly. They'd been losing $30k deals just by forgetting to call people back in the truck.
What Happened
The Reality
Beyond the numbers, here's what actually mattered: They stopped getting calls from people they couldn't help. Every lead that came in was qualified. They were having conversations with decision-makers instead of tire-kickers.
Six months in, revenue had doubled. Not because we were brilliant. Because we finally figured out who they were actually for.
What I Learned
This project reinforced something I see all the time: businesses think they need more customers when they actually need better customers.
They were getting plenty of traffic. They were getting plenty of leads. They were just getting the wrong leads.
Narrowing their focus felt scary to them. "What if we turn away business?" But turning away the wrong business made room for the right business.
What This Means for You
- → If you're getting traffic but not the right leads, your problem isn't marketing volume. It's positioning clarity.
- → If you're competing on price, you probably haven't narrowed your focus enough.
- → If your website is trying to appeal to everyone, it's probably converting nobody.